An upper limit to the photon fraction in cosmic rays above 10(19) eV from the Pierre Auger Observatory

Abraham, J; Aglietta, M; Aguirre, C; Allard, D; Allekotte, I; Allison, P; Alvarez, C; Alvarez Muniz, J; Ambrosio, M; Anchordoqui, L; Anjos, Jc; Aramo, C; Arisaka, K; Armengaud, E; Arneodo, F; Arqueros, F; Asch, T; Asorey, H; Atulugama, Bs; Aublin, J; Ave, M; Avila, G; Bacelar, J; Backer, T; Badagnani, D; Barbosa, Af; Barbosa, Hmj; Barkhausen, M; Barnhill, D; Barroso, Slc; Bauleo, P; Beatty, J; Beau, T; Becker, Br; Becker, Kh; Bellido, Ja; Benzvi, S; Berat, C; Bergmann, T; Bernardini, P; Bertou, X; Biermann, Pl; Billoir, P; Blanch Bigas, O; Blanco, F; Blasi, P; Bleve, C; Blumer, H; Boghrat, P; Bohacova, M; Bonifazi, C; Bonino, R; Boratav, M; Brack, J; Brunet, Jm; Buchholz, P; Busca, Ng; Caballero Mora KS,; Cai, B; Camin, Dv; Capdevielle, Jn; Caruso, Rossella; Castellina, A; Cataldi, G; Cazon, L; Cester, R; Chauvin, J; Chiavassa, A; Chinellato, Ja; Chou, A; Chye, J; Claes, D; Clark, Pdj; Clay, Rw; Clay, Sb; Connolly, B; Cordier, A; Cotti, U; Coutu, S; Covault, Ce; Cronin, J; Dagoret Campagne, S; Quang, Td; Darriulat, P; Daumiller, K; Dawson, Br; de Almeida RM,; de Carvalho LA,; De Donato, C; de Jong SJ,; de Mello WJM,; Neto, Jrtd; De Mitri, I; de Oliveira MAL,; de Souza, V; del Peral, L; Deligny, O; Della Selva, A; Delle Fratte, C; Dembinski, H; Di Giulio, C; Diaz, Jc; Dobrigkeit, C; D'Olivo, Jc; Dornic, D; Dorofeev, A; Dova, Mt; D'Urso, D; Duvernois, Ma; Engel, R; Epele, L; Erdmann, M; Escobar, Co; Etchegoyen, A; Ewers, A; San Luis PF,; Falcke, H; Fauth, Ac; Fazio, D; Fazzini, N; Fernandez, A; Ferrer, F; Ferry, S; Fick, B; Filevich, A; Filipcic, A; Fleck, I; Fokitis, E; Fonte, R; Fuhrmann, D; Fulgione, W; Garcia, B; Garcia Pinto, D; Garrard, L; Garrido, X; Geenen, H; Gelmini, G; Gemmeke, H; Geranios, A; Ghia, Pl; Giller, M; Gitto, J; Glass, H; Gobbi, F; Gold, Ms; Albarracin, Fg; Berisso, Mg; Herrero, Rg; do Amaral MG,; Gongora, Jp; Gonzalez, D; Gonzalez, Jg; Gonzalez, M; Gora, D; Gorgi, A; Gouffon, P; Grassi, V; Grillo, A; Grunfeld, C; Grupen, C; Guarino, F; Guedes, Gp; Gutierrez, J; Hague, Jd; Hamilton, Jc; Harakeh, Mn; Harari, D; Harmsma, S; Hartmann, S; Harton, Jl; Healy, Md; Hebbeker, T; Heck, D; Hojvat, C; Homola, P; Horandel, J; Horneffer, A; Horvat, M; Hrabovsky, M; Iarlori, M; Insolia, Antonio; Kaducak, M; Kalashev, O; Kampert, Kh; Keilhauer, B; Kemp, E; Klages, Ho; Kleifges, M; Kleinfeller, J; Knapik, R; Knapp, J; Koang, Dh; Kolotaev, Y; Kopmann, A; Kromer, O; Kuhlman, S; Kuijpers, J; Kunka, N; Kusenko, A; Lachaud, C; Lago, Bl; Lebrun, D; Lebrun, P; Lee, J; Letessier Selvon, A; Leuthold, M; Lhenry Yvon, I; Longo, G; Lopez, R; Agura, Al; Lucero, A; Maldera, S; Malek, M; Maltezos, S; Mancarella, G; Mancenido, Me; Mandat, D; Mantsch, P; Mariazzi, Ag; Maris, Ic; Martello, D; Martinez, N; Martinez, J; Martinez, O; Mathes, Hj; Matthews, J; Matthews, Jaj; Matthiae, G; Maurin, G; Maurizio, D; Mazur, Po; Mccauley, T; Mcewen, M; Mcneil, Rr; Medina, G; Medina, Mc; Tanco, Gm; Meli, A; Melo, D; Menichetti, E; Menshikov, A; Meurer, C; Meyhandan, R; Micheletti, Mi; Miele, G; Miller, W; Mollerach, S; Monasor, M; Ragaigne, Dm; Montanet, F; Morales, B; Morello, C; Moreno, E; Morris, C; Mostafa, M; Muller, Ma; Mussa, R; Navarra, G; Nellen, L; Newman Holmes, C; Newton, D; Thi, Tn; Nichol, R; Nierstenhofer, N; Nitz, D; Nogima, H; Nosek, D; Nozka, L; Oehlschlager, J; Ohnuki, T; Olinto, A; Oliveira, Lfa; Olmos Gilbaja VM,; Ortiz, M; Ostapchenko, S; Otero, L; Palatka, M; Pallotta, J; Parente, G; Parizot, E; Parlati, S; Patel, M; Paul, T; Payet, K; Pech, M; Pekala, J; Pelayo, R; Pepe, Im; Perrone, L; Petrera, S; Petrinca, P; Petrov, Y; Ngoc, Dp; Thi, Tnp; Piegaia, R; Pierog, T; Pisanti, O; Porter, Ta; Pouryamout, J; Prado, L; Privitera, P; Prouza, M; Quel, Ej; Rautenberg, J; Reis, Hc; Reucroft, S; Revenu, B; Ridky, J; Risi, A; Risse, M; Riviere, C; Rizi, V; Robbins, S; Roberts, M; Robledo, C; Rodriguez, G; Frias, Dr; Martino, Jr; Rojo, Jr; Ros, G; Roulet, E; Rovero, Ac; Rosado, J; Roth, M; Roucelle, C; Rouille d'Orfeuil, B; Roulet, E; Rovero, Ac; Salamida, F; Salazar, H; Salina, G; Sanchez, F; Santander, M; Santos, Em; Sarkar, S; Sato, R; Scherini, V; Schmidt, T; Scholten, O; Schovanek, P; Schussler, F; Sciutto, Sj; Scuderi, M; Semikoz, D; Sequeiros, G; Shellard, Rc; Siffert, Bb; Sigl, G; Skelton, P; Slater, W; De Grande NS,; Smialkowski, A; Smida, R; Smith, Be; Snow, Gr; Sokolsky, P; Sommers, P; Sorokin, J; Spinka, H; Strazzeri, E; Stutz, A; Suarez, F; Suomijarvi, T; Supanitsky, Ad; Swain, J; Szadkowski, Z; Tamashiro, A; Tamburro, A; Tascau, O; Ticona, R; Timmermans, C; Tkaczyk, W; Peixoto, Cjt; Tonachini, A; Torresi, D; Travnicek, P; Tripathi, A; Tristram, G; Tscherniakhovski, D; Tueros, M; Tunnicliffe, V; Ulrich, R; Unger, M; Urban, M; Galicia, Jfv; Valino, I; Valore, L; van den Berg AM,; van Elewyck, V; Vazquez, Ra; Veberic, D; Veiga, A; Velarde, A; Venters, T; Verzi, V; Videla, M; Villasenor, L; Van, Tv; Vorobiov, S; Voyvodic, L; Wahlberg, H; Wainberg, O; Waldenmaier, T; Walker, P; Warner, D; Watson, Aa; Westerhoff, S; Wiebusch, C; Wieczorek, G; Wiencke, L; Wilczynska, B; Wilczynski, H; Wileman, C; Winnick, Mg; Xu, J; Yamamoto, T; Younk, P; Zas, E; Zavrtanik, D; Zavrtanik, M; Zech, A; Zepeda, A; Zha, M; Ziolkowski, M.

doi:10.1016/j.astropartphys.2006.10.004

An upper limit of 16% (at 95% c.l.) is derived for the photon fraction in cosmic rays with energies greater than 10(19) eV, based on observations of the depth of shower maximum performed with the hybrid detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory. This is the first such limit on photons obtained by observing the fluorescence light profile of air showers. This upper limit confirms and improves on previous results from the Haverah Park and AGASA surface arrays. Additional data recorded with the Auger surface detectors for a subset of the event sample support the conclusion that a photon origin of the observed events is not favored. (c) 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. RI Zavrtanik, Marko/A-1524-2008; Nichol, Ryan/C-1645-2008; Aramo, Carla/D-4317-2011; Beatty, James/D-9310-2011; Kemp, Ernesto/H-1502-2011; Chiavassa, Andrea/A-7597-2012; Verzi, Valerio/B-1149-2012; Chinellato, Carola Dobrigkeit /F-2540-2011; Venters, Tonia/D-2936-2012; Barbosa, Henrique/F-3499-2012; Fauth, Anderson/F-9570-2012; de souza, Vitor/D-1381-2012; Shellard, Ronald/G-4825-2012; Wiebusch, Christopher/G-6490-2012; Miele, Gennaro/F-3628-2010; Muller, Marcio Aparecido/H-9112-2012; fulgione, walter/I-5232-2012; D'Urso, Domenico/I-5325-2012; Valino, Ines/J-8324-2012; Chinellato, Jose Augusto/I-7972-2012; Tamburro, Alessio/A-5703-2013; Bleve, Carla/J-2521-2012; Kopmann, Andreas/B-3454-2013; Falcke, Heino/H-5262-2012; Arneodo, Francesco/B-8076-2013; Gomez-Herrero, Raul/B-7346-2011; Anjos, Joao/C-8335-2013; Sarkar, Subir/G-5978-2011; Schussler, Fabian/G-5313-2013 OI Zavrtanik, Marko/0000-0001-5606-6912; Shellard, Ronald/0000-0002-2983-1815; D'Urso, Domenico/0000-0002-8215-4542; Falcke, Heino/0000-0002-2526-6724; Arneodo, Francesco/0000-0002-1061-0510; Gomez-Herrero, Raul/0000-0002-5705-9236; Sarkar, Subir/0000-0002-3542-858X; Schussler, Fabian/0000-0003-1500-6571