Necessary and possible preference structures

A classical approach to model a preference on a set A of alternatives uses a reflexive, transitive and complete binary relation, i.e. a total preorder. Since the axioms of a total preorder do not usually hold in many applications, preferences are often modeled by means of weaker binary relations, dropping either completeness (e.g. partial preorders) or transitivity (e.g. interval orders and semiorders). We introduce an alternative approach to preference modeling, which uses two binary relations – the necessary preference N and the possible preference P – to fulfill completeness and transitivity in a mixed form. Formally, a NaP-preference (necessary and possible preference) on A is a pair (N,P) such that N is a partial preorder on A and P is an extension of N satisfying mixed properties of transitivity and completeness. We characterize a NaP-preference (N,P) by the existence of a nonempty set R of total preorders whose intersection and union is equal to, respectively, N and P. In order to analyze the representability of NaP-preferences via families of utility functions, we generalize the notion of a multi-utility representation of a partial preorder by that of a modal utility representation of a pair of binary relations. Further, we give a dynamic view of the family of all NaP-preferences on a fixed set AA by endowing it with a relation of partial order, which is defined according to the stability of the information represented by each NaP-preference.